"We love the company, we believe in the market, but we're not convinced the team can execute our growth plan."
I hear some version of this statement nearly every week from PE firms conducting due diligence. The challenge? Most don't have a systematic approach to evaluating whether a target company's leadership and organization can actually deliver on post-acquisition expectations.
Having supported dozens of pre-investment assessments, we've seen firsthand how even sophisticated PE firms often rely on gut feel and superficial reference checks when it comes to human capital. The same firms that would never accept a financial model without rigorous analysis will make multi-million dollar bets on leadership teams based on a handful of meetings and vague impressions.
The results are predictable: 72% of deal teams later admit they overestimated the target company's ability to execute their post-acquisition growth plan.
But there's a better way. The most successful PE investors have developed systematic approaches to human capital due diligence that go far beyond traditional leadership assessment. Through our work supporting these firms, we've seen how comprehensive talent evaluation can uncover execution risks that financial models miss—and identify opportunities that others overlook.
In this article, we'll share the frameworks and approaches that are transforming how PE firms evaluate the people behind the performance. This isn't just about avoiding bad deals—it's about creating more realistic value creation plans and setting the stage for post-acquisition success.
PE Perspective: Framework for Evaluating Organizational Structure and Talent
Beyond the Executive Team: A Comprehensive Approach to Talent Evaluation
Traditional human capital due diligence often focused narrowly on the CEO and CFO. Today's most successful PE firms take a more comprehensive approach, recognizing that value creation depends on capabilities throughout the organization.
We used to just look at the top executives during due diligence, but now we dig deeper. We’re talking about the whole organization – its setup, skills, vibe, and how they manage their people. This wider view means we catch potential problems and good opportunities that we’d miss otherwise.
This comprehensive approach typically includes four key dimensions:
1. Leadership Assessment: Evaluating Execution Capability
The evaluation of leadership goes far beyond basic background checks and reference calls. Leading PE firms now employ sophisticated assessment methodologies to gauge whether executives can execute the specific value creation plan envisioned for the company.
Modern leadership assessment in PE due diligence examines:
Strategic Alignment: Does the leadership team fully understand and embrace the potential value creation opportunities? Are they prepared to shift strategic direction if necessary?
Some leaders who performed well in the past may struggle when goals change. It's important to assess whether they are open to new directions and can adapt to a new strategy.
Performance Orientation: How does the leadership team define and measure success? Do they hold themselves and others accountable for results?
Change Agility: Has the team successfully led significant organizational change? How do they approach resistance and obstacles?
Complementary Skills: Do the executives have the right mix of skills to execute the value creation plan? Are there critical gaps that need to be addressed?
Aligning talent capabilities with the objectives of a value creation plan allows companies to proactively identify gaps and strategically plan for future hiring needs.
Scalability: Can current leaders manage a larger, more complex organization? Have they demonstrated the ability to scale in previous roles?
Cohesion: How effectively does the leadership team work together? Are there underlying tensions or factions that could impede execution?
These assessments typically involve structured interviews, psychometric assessments, references from previous private equity backers, and simulations of challenging scenarios the team might face post-acquisition.
2. Organizational Structure Analysis: Optimizing for Value Creation
The configuration of an organization can either accelerate or inhibit value creation. During due diligence, forward-thinking PE firms analyze whether the current structure aligns with the intended strategy.
Businesses often find their organizational structure is outdated and misaligned with their current goals or future direction. This can lead to inefficiencies and slowdowns in innovation and growth.
Key structural elements evaluated during due diligence include:
Decision Rights: How are decisions made? Are they appropriately centralized or decentralized based on the business model and growth strategy?
Spans and Layers: Is the organization unnecessarily complex with too many management layers? Could flattening the structure improve both cost and agility?
Functional Capability: Are critical functions properly resourced and positioned within the organization? Are there capabilities missing that will be needed to execute the value creation plan?
Reporting Relationships: Do reporting structures create clear accountability for key value drivers? Are there conflicting incentives embedded in the structure?
Resource Allocation: How does the company determine where to invest resources? Does the allocation process align with value creation priorities?
This analysis helps PE firms identify structural changes that should be implemented post-acquisition and determine whether current leaders can execute these changes effectively.
3. Cultural Assessment: Evaluating the Human Operating System
Culture—the unwritten rules that govern behavior in an organization—can be a powerful accelerator of value creation or a significant impediment to change. Leading PE firms now incorporate cultural assessment into their due diligence process.
Company culture is about more than just employee satisfaction. It's about whether the company's implicit rules and expectations align with the changes needed to drive the business forward. A culture that was successful in the past may not be suitable for future endeavors.
Cultural assessment in PE due diligence typically examines:
Decision-Making Norms: How does the organization make decisions? Is it consensus-driven or hierarchical? Fast or methodical? Does this approach align with future needs?
Performance Orientation: How does the organization view performance and accountability? Are underperformers managed effectively?
Risk Tolerance: How does the company approach risk and innovation? Is there an appropriate balance between caution and boldness?
External Orientation: Is the organization customer-focused and market-aware? Or is it primarily internally focused?
Change Readiness: How has the organization responded to previous change initiatives? Is there inherent resistance to new approaches?
Cultural assessment during due diligence typically involves using a combination of tools such as surveys, observation, and interviews to understand the current culture and its alignment with the investment thesis. This helps to gauge the likely pace of change and identify potential areas of resistance.
4. Talent Management Infrastructure: Assessing the People Engine
The systems and processes a company uses to attract, develop, and retain talent directly impact its ability to execute a value creation plan. During due diligence, sophisticated PE firms evaluate these capabilities to determine whether they'll support or hinder future growth.
Key elements of talent infrastructure assessment include:
Recruiting Effectiveness: How does the company source and select talent? Are there pipelines for critical roles? Does the company have a compelling employment brand?
Performance Management: Are there clear objectives and accountabilities? How are performance issues addressed? Is compensation aligned with value creation?
Development Processes: How does the organization build needed capabilities? Is there a focus on developing high-potential talent?
Succession Planning: Are there identified successors for key roles? How robust is the leadership pipeline?
Retention Mechanisms: What strategies are in place to retain critical talent through the transaction and beyond?
Companies with strong talent management infrastructure create value faster post-acquisition. They can more quickly adapt to new strategic priorities because they already have the systems to align people with objectives. Companies lacking these capabilities often stall during the critical first year while these systems are being built.
The Integration of Human Capital Insights
The most sophisticated PE firms don't treat these elements as isolated assessments but integrate human capital insights with financial and operational due diligence to form a comprehensive view of the investment opportunity.
Human capital insights play a big role in investment strategies, valuations, and forecasting. Needing to beef up the leadership team can mess with costs and schedules, while top-notch talent can definitely boost a company's value.
This integration ensures that human capital realities are reflected in the investment decision and planning, not discovered as surprises post-acquisition.
Portfolio Perspective: Preparing Your Team for Investor Scrutiny
Understanding PE Human Capital Expectations
For company leaders preparing for potential PE investment, understanding investor expectations around human capital can significantly improve both the due diligence process and post-acquisition relationship.
Many companies are surprised by the intense scrutiny of their talent, organization, and culture during private equity due diligence.
Company leaders should understand that PE investors approach human capital with specific priorities:
Value Creation Focus: PE firms evaluate talent primarily through the lens of your ability to execute their value creation plan, which may differ from your current strategy.
Transformation Capability: Investors assess whether your team can lead significant change, not just maintain current operations.
Scalability: PE firms examine whether your organization can grow substantially during their ownership period.
Accountability: Investors look for a culture and systems that drive consistent performance and address shortfalls promptly.
Efficiency: PE firms evaluate whether your organizational structure and processes are optimized for both effectiveness and cost.
Proactive Preparation Strategies
Companies considering PE investment can take several steps to prepare for human capital due diligence and position themselves as attractive candidates:
1. Conduct a Pre-Due Diligence Talent Assessment
Before engaging with potential investors, smart leadership teams conduct their own talent assessment to identify strengths and gaps. This allows them to address issues proactively or prepare thoughtful explanations and plans.
One CEO explains that their company hired an independent consultant to evaluate their leadership team against the capabilities needed for their next growth phase well in advance of speaking to any PE firms. This highlighted several gaps that they were able to address proactively. When due diligence raised these same areas, they could show that they'd already identified and solved the issues.
This self-assessment should mirror the dimensions PE firms will evaluate: leadership capabilities, organizational structure, culture, and talent management processes.
2. Align Your Leadership Team
Ensuring your leadership team presents a unified vision during due diligence is essential. This doesn't mean scripting responses, but rather making sure everyone understands the growth strategy and their role in executing it.
Significant time should be spent aligning the executive team before due diligence. Growth strategy, potential investor questions, and areas where team members have differing perspectives should be discussed. This will allow the team to present a cohesive vision while remaining authentic in individual interactions with potential investors.
This alignment should include candid discussions about how a PE investment might change the organization and each leader's role. Having these conversations before due diligence helps identify who is truly committed to the next phase of growth.
3. Document Your Talent Strategy
Having a clear, documented approach to talent management demonstrates sophistication to potential investors. This should include:
Strategic Workforce Planning: Documentation of future talent needs based on your growth strategy.
Organizational Design Principles: Clear rationale for your current structure and how it might evolve.
Succession Plans: Identified successors for key roles and development plans for high-potential talent.
Performance Management Approach: How you set objectives, evaluate performance, and address capability gaps.
Recruiting Strategy: Your approach to attracting and selecting talent for critical roles.
Having well-documented talent processes can make a good impression on potential investors, as it demonstrates that the company values its talent. While investors may suggest improvements, established systems show that the company is well-prepared.
4. Prepare for Sensitive Talent Discussions
Due diligence will inevitably raise sensitive questions about team member capabilities and performance. Preparing for these discussions allows you to address them professionally rather than defensively.
Company leaders should prepare to discuss:
Team Member Performance: Honest assessments of each leader's strengths and development areas.
Capability Gaps: Roles where you may need to upgrade talent to achieve growth objectives.
Succession Readiness: How prepared you are for potential departures of key employees.
Development Plans: How you're building capabilities needed for future growth.
5. Demonstrate Cultural Self-Awareness
PE firms recognize that culture significantly impacts value creation potential. Companies that demonstrate cultural self-awareness—understanding both the strengths and limitations of their current culture—appear more sophisticated to investors.
Conducting a cultural assessment before engaging with potential investors can be beneficial for companies. This allows the company to clearly communicate which aspects of their culture have contributed to their success and which aspects may need to change as a result of the investment. This demonstrates to investors that the company understands the cultural implications of the partnership.
This cultural self-assessment should address:
Current Cultural Strengths: What elements of your culture drive performance and should be preserved?
Cultural Evolution Needs: What aspects of your culture might hinder the execution of a more ambitious growth plan?
Change Readiness: How adaptable is your organization to new approaches and increased performance expectations?
Cultural Integration: If your growth strategy includes acquisitions, how will you approach cultural integration?
The IQTalent Advantage: Supporting Human Capital Due Diligence
Human capital due diligence often identifies talent gaps that need to be addressed quickly post-acquisition. IQTalent provides unique value to both PE firms and portfolio companies during this critical phase:
For PE Firms:
Rapid Talent Gap Closure: IQTalent's on-demand model allows immediate deployment of recruiting resources to address leadership gaps identified during due diligence.
Specialist Expertise: Access to recruiters with expertise in specific functions or industries relevant to the portfolio company's needs.
Flexible Engagement: Ability to scale recruiting resources up during intensive post-acquisition hiring and then adjust as needs normalize.
Cost Efficiency: On-demand model eliminates the fixed costs of building an internal recruiting team at the portfolio company.
For Portfolio Companies:
Acquisition Readiness: IQTalent helps companies prepare for PE scrutiny by strengthening key positions before engaging with investors.
Post-Acquisition Support: Flexible recruiting resources to quickly address talent gaps identified during due diligence.
Specialization Without Overhead: Access to specialized recruiting expertise without long-term fixed costs.
Scalability: Recruiting support that can expand or contract based on changing business needs throughout the PE ownership period.
Key Takeaways: Maximizing Value Through Human Capital Due Diligence
Human capital due diligence has evolved from a peripheral concern to a central element of PE investment decision-making. Both investors and companies benefit from approaching this process strategically:
For PE Firms: Comprehensive human capital assessment provides deeper insight into value creation potential and execution risks. By integrating talent evaluation with financial and operational due diligence, firms can develop more realistic investment theses and post-acquisition plans.
For Portfolio Companies: Proactive preparation for talent scrutiny positions companies as sophisticated partners for PE investors. By conducting self-assessments and addressing gaps before due diligence begins, companies can improve both their valuation and post-acquisition experience.
The most successful PE investments occur when both parties approach human capital due diligence as a collaborative opportunity to identify the talent strategy that will maximize value creation.
In our next article, we'll explore "The Scale-Up Imperative"—how PE firms assess a portfolio company's readiness to scale and how companies can create structured hiring plans post-investment.
Never miss an installment in our PE Talent Strategy Series. Sign up here to receive each new installment in your inbox. Wondering how IQTalent can help you with your talent strategy? Let's talk!
